Contra indicators for each quadrant

Personal Impact

  • Displays inconsistent behaviour and fails to keep commitments
  • Fails to understand or appreciate impact on others; does not consider situation from others’ viewpoint
  • Spends little time on personal and professional development activities
  • Exhibits aggressive, defensive, overpowering, bullying, or defensive behaviour
  • Does not lead by example or stand by own principles or spoken beliefs
  • Offers advice beyond boundaries of knowledge or experience
  • Applies preconceptions and stereotyping in dealings with others
  • Is unwilling to share expertise with others; or withholds relevant information, expertise or knowledge
  • Does not contribute willingly to the team and adopts a passive role
  • Refuses to acknowledge personal mistakes

Outstanding Leadership 

  • Displays obstructive behaviours rather than progressive ones
  • Tends to apportion blame and accountability to others when things go wrong
  • Makes unrealistic promises about what can be delivered
  • Unwilling to recognise, or deal with, capability or performance issues in self or others; avoids difficult conversations and confrontation
  • Challenges others in a way that intimidates or undermines
  • Gives little time to the development of peers and colleagues
  • Shows stubbornness in the face of opposition, even when proved wrong
  • Shows general lack of confidence in own knowledge, abilities and judgements
  • Sits on the fence rather than taking a clear stand
  • Shows little consideration or respect for other colleagues
  • Fails to allow others to put in different views in meetings

Service Delivery 

  • Does not focus on a drive to improve service delivery
  • Is preoccupied with own or hidden agenda rather than the needs of staff, customers, clients or partner agencies
  • Doesn’t take into account local needs
  • Fails to appreciate the need to engage the support of stakeholders
  • Consistently works in isolation, pursuing own solution without involvement of appropriate stakeholders
  • Fails to build contact with people beyond own work area
  • Fails to recognise the value of diversity
  • Works in an unfocused way, failing to prioritise, keep track of progress, or adapt approach when deadlines, targets or standards are threatened or changed
  • Gives up in the face of obstacles and does not demonstrate a sense of personal responsibility for delivery

Organisational Effectiveness

  • Obstructive towards learning or progress
  • Fails to see relevance of wider organisation issues, sector trends or contextual developments to organisation or role; fails to communicate these
  • Needs to know all the answers, rather than the right method of enquiry
  • Rejects ideas quickly or spontaneously without reflection or adequate insights
  • Is focused on the present and the past and has a low interest in emergent or future issues
  • Avoids long-standing, difficult or sensitive issues
  • Focuses on symptoms rather than causes
  • Fails to understand organisation decision-making processes (explicit or implicit) and how these translate into personal authorities
  • Overlooks inappropriate behaviour with regard to the organisation’s processes, values and expected behaviours
Loading...